Skip to content
Henry Yip
Henry Yip

Henry Yip

MSc Physics student at ETH Zürich. Tropical cyclones, atmospheric modelling and machine learning for weather prediction.

Plane Crash Problem: How Long Does It Take to Fall?

This problem came out of a conversation in Shenzhen: does a falling plane reach a higher terminal velocity than a falling person, and how long does the fall take? We first solve the problem with constant air density, then let the density decrease exponentially with altitude.

Constant air density

Take downwards as positive and model air resistance as quadratic drag, \(kv^2\) with \(k > 0\). Newton’s second law gives a separable equation:

\[\begin{aligned} m \frac{dv}{dt}&=mg-kv^2 \\ \frac{m\,dv}{mg-kv^2}&=dt \\ t&=\int_{0}^{v} \frac{m\,dv'}{mg-kv'^2}, \end{aligned}\]

where we assumed the object starts from rest, \(v(0)=0\).

To evaluate the integral, substitute \(u=\sqrt{\frac{k}{mg}}\, v\), so that \(dv = \sqrt{\frac{mg}{k}}\, du\):

\[\begin{aligned} t &= \frac{m}{mg}\sqrt{\frac{mg}{k}} \int_0^{u} \frac{d u'}{1-u'^2} \\ &= \sqrt{\frac{m}{gk}}\, \tanh^{-1}\!\left(v \sqrt{\frac{k}{m g}}\right). \end{aligned}\]

Inverting,

\[v(t)=\sqrt {\frac{mg}{k}}\,\tanh \left( t \sqrt{\frac{gk}{m}} \right).\]

As \(t \to \infty\), \(\tanh \to 1\), so the terminal velocity is

\[v_\text{T}=\sqrt{\frac{mg}{k}}.\]

To find \(k\), use the drag equation for turbulent flow, \(F_{\mathrm{d}}=\frac{1}{2} \rho\, c_{\mathrm{d}} A v^2\), so \(k = \frac12 \rho\, c_d A\) and

\[v_\text{T}=\sqrt{\frac{2mg}{\rho\, c_d A}}.\]

The terminal velocity grows like \(\sqrt{m/(c_d A)}\). A plane’s mass per unit frontal area is far larger than a person’s, so a falling plane reaches a much higher terminal velocity. With the values used in the calculation below, a skydiver (\(m = 80\text{ kg}\), \(k = 0.25\text{ kg m}^{-1}\)) reaches \(56\text{ m s}^{-1}\) and an airliner (\(m = 60\text{ t}\), \(k = 11\text{ kg m}^{-1}\)) reaches \(231\text{ m s}^{-1}\).

Altitude-dependent air density

Air thins out with height. A simple model is an exponential atmosphere,

\[\rho(h)=\rho_0\,e^{-h/H},\]

where \(H\) is the scale height (about \(8\text{ km}\) for Earth). We now look for the speed \(v\) as a function of the altitude \(h\).

With downwards still positive, the equations of motion are

\[m\frac{dv}{dt}=m g - k\,e^{-h/H}\,v^2, \qquad \frac{dh}{dt}=-v,\]

with \(k=\tfrac12\,\rho_0\,c_d\,A\) the drag constant at sea level.

1. Change of independent variable

Trade the time derivative for an \(h\)-derivative:

\[\frac{dv}{dt} =\frac{dv}{dh}\,\frac{dh}{dt} =-\,v\,\frac{dv}{dh}.\]

Setting \(u(h)=v(h)^2\), the equation of motion becomes linear in \(u\):

\[\frac{du}{dh} -\frac{2k}{m}\,e^{-h/H}\,u =-2g.\]

2. Integrating factor

The integrating factor is

\[\begin{aligned} \mu(h) &=\exp\left(-\frac{2k}{m}\int e^{-h/H}\,dh\right) \\ &=\exp\left(\frac{2kH}{m}\,e^{-h/H}\right). \end{aligned}\]

Multiplying the equation by \(\mu\) and integrating from the initial altitude \(h_0\), where the object starts from rest (\(u(h_0)=0\)),

\[\frac{d}{dh}\bigl(u\,\mu\bigr) =-2g\,\mu(h),\]

so

\[u(h)\,\mu(h) =-2g \int_{h_0}^{h}\mu(s)\,ds.\]

The remaining integral is an exponential integral. With \(w = \frac{2kH}{m}e^{-s/H}\) we have \(ds = -H\,dw/w\), so

\[\int e^{\frac{2kH}{m}e^{-s/H}}\,ds = -H\,\operatorname{Ei}\left(\frac{2kH}{m}e^{-s/H}\right) + C.\]

3. Speed as a function of altitude

Define

\[y = \frac{2kH}{m}\,e^{-h/H}, \qquad y_0 = \frac{2kH}{m}\,e^{-h_0/H}.\]

Then

\[v(h)^2 = 2gH\, e^{-y}\left[\operatorname{Ei}(y) - \operatorname{Ei}(y_0)\right],\]

so

\[\boxed{ v(h) =\sqrt{2gH}\; e^{-y/2}\, \sqrt{ \operatorname{Ei}(y) -\operatorname{Ei}(y_0) } }.\]

Since \(h < h_0\) we have \(y > y_0\), and \(\operatorname{Ei}\) is increasing for positive arguments, so the square root is real.

4. Time as a function of altitude

The time to fall from \(h_0\) to \(h\) is

\[t(h)=\int_{h}^{h_0}\frac{dh'}{v(h')},\]

and unlike the constant-density case this integral has no elementary closed form, so in practice it is evaluated numerically. For example, a skydiver with \(m = 80\text{ kg}\) and \(k = 0.25\text{ kg m}^{-1}\), falling from rest at \(h_0 = 10\text{ km}\) with \(H = 8\text{ km}\), is moving at \(64.3\text{ m s}^{-1}\) when passing \(2\text{ km}\), about \(104\text{ s}\) later. A direct numerical integration of the equations of motion agrees with both numbers.

5. Recovering the constant-density result

As \(H\to\infty\) the atmosphere becomes uniform. Both \(y\) and \(y_0\) then tend to infinity, while their difference stays finite:

\[\begin{aligned} y - y_0 &= \frac{2kH}{m}\left(e^{-h/H}-e^{-h_0/H}\right) \\ &\longrightarrow \frac{2k}{m}(h_0 - h). \end{aligned}\]

For large arguments \(\operatorname{Ei}(x) \sim e^x/x\), so

\[\begin{aligned} v(h)^2 &\approx 2gH\left[\frac{1}{y} - \frac{e^{-(y-y_0)}}{y_0}\right] \\ &\longrightarrow \frac{mg}{k}\left[1 - e^{-2k(h_0-h)/m}\right]. \end{aligned}\]

This is exactly the constant-density result written in terms of the distance fallen, \(s = h_0 - h\). Indeed, integrating \(v(t)=\sqrt{mg/k}\,\tanh\bigl(t\sqrt{gk/m}\bigr)\) gives \(s(t) = \frac{m}{k}\ln\cosh\bigl(t\sqrt{gk/m}\bigr)\), so \(e^{-2ks/m} = \operatorname{sech}^2\bigl(t\sqrt{gk/m}\bigr)\) and \(v^2 = \frac{mg}{k}\left(1-e^{-2ks/m}\right)\). The exponential-atmosphere solution therefore reduces smoothly to the familiar \(\tanh\) law.

Live calculation

A fall from rest, in an exponential atmosphere and with constant air density

Time to the ground
–
…with constant density
–
Speed at the ground
–
Fastest point
–
Formula and numerics
–

Computed in your browser with fourth-order Runge–Kutta steps of 0.05 s. Top: speed against time. In the thin air high up, the object falls faster than its sea-level terminal velocity, then slows down as the air thickens; with constant density (dashed) it just approaches the terminal velocity. Bottom: speed against altitude for the exponential atmosphere, with the closed-form v(h) from section 3 marked every 500 m. Hover over a curve for its values.

Exercises

  • Why is the constant-density equation separable? (Undergraduate, year 1)
  • Repeat the analysis for air resistance proportional to \(v\). (Undergraduate, years 1–2)
  • With no air resistance at all, what are the “terminal velocities” of the plane and the person? Why? (Secondary school)

Revised on 25 October 2026. The boxed formula for the fall time when the air density decreases with height was wrong. For a skydiver (80 kg) falling from 10 km to 2 km it gives about \(-3 \times 10^{-6}\) s, a negative time, while integrating the equations of motion gives about 104 s. The formula for the speed was correct. The time formula is replaced by the correct integral, and the constant-density derivation is cleaned up. The difficulty label “HKDSE F4” is now “secondary school”.

Filed under .